Direct Selling vs Direct Marketing

What’s the Difference Between Direct Selling and Direct Marketing?

There are many ways to entice consumers to buy your products or services. We will compare two of the popular strategies used by many businesses around the globe: direct selling and direct marketing. We will also discuss direct mail, which is a subcategory of direct marketing. You’ll find out how these strategies work and the key differences between them. If you’re trying to figure out which one is the best for your business, keep reading as I’ll provide some examples.

What is Direct Selling?

Direct sales or direct selling involves the direct selling of products or services to consumers without going through the traditional process like retail stores. The products go from the manufacturer to a direct sales company.

Some direct sales companies will provide commissions for the sale of each product. This is similar to how online affiliate programs work, but the key difference is that the modern affiliate models don’t require their affiliates to store inventory.

Another model for direct sales is through a multi-tiered model where you invite your friends to become direct sales reps. From there, commissions are earned through multiple tiers of your organization, the people that you’ve directly or indirectly recruited as sales reps. This is often referred to as network marketing or MLM.

Direct selling can be done through 1-on-1 sales or 1-to-many presentations. I prefer doing 1-to-many sales presentations if possible. Traditionally, people would sell to many through educational workshops or seminars offline. Another traditional approach through the telephone using a teleconference provider. Nowadays, it’s popular to use an internet-based model where you can do direct selling through a webinar (web seminar) system. This allows you to have a 2-way interaction with prospective buyers.

What is Direct Marketing?

Direct marketing or direct response marketing is an advertising campaign designed to elicit actions from a specific group of consumers. Such actions could be an order, a subscription, contacting you for more information, or visiting your website.

Direct marketing is efficient for small business with little budget or no budget for brand marketing. If you’re not sure what I mean by brand marketing, check out how Apple rolls with their branding campaigns.

Direct marketing gives you customer response which can be measured. What we mean by measured is that you know what type of advertisement made the customer response to you. So you can check out what types of advertisements are not giving you a return on your investment.

In some cases, a brand can be developed from successful direct marketing campaigns. A good example of this is the transformation of The Quaker Oats Company, one of the most popular oatmeal companies here in the United States. Claude C. Hopkins, was a well-known copywriter that helped catapult the struggling company into success with his legendary “Food shot from guns of peace” direct response ad. The company probably wouldn’t be around if it wasn’t for this ad. Many of today’s direct response concepts were made popular from Claude’s scientific advertising methods from the early 1900s.

Claude Hopkins - Puffed Oats

What is Direct Mail?

Direct mail falls under the direct marketing category. Direct mail is specifically designed to market your products through printed advertisement to a specific contact or contact list. This list usually is either emails and home or business address. Direct mail is designed to personalize an advertisement to have a high response rate.

You may notice an email from businesses you subscribe to in your inbox with all sorts of limited and exclusive offer that is applicable to your consuming trend. That is how direct mail works. When I first got started in direct mail, I was doing most of the grunt work from my kitchen table. I had a roll of bulk stamps, pre-printed postcards, and a bunch of hustle. This routine works well if you can create highly effective ads.

If you’re interested in direct response marketing or direct mail, make sure that you check out my interview with Jim Straw. The guy is a direct marketing legend and sold $400 million dollars worth of products using direct mail.

What’s the Difference Between Direct Sales and Direct Marketing?

Both works to entice consumers to buy your products. Both also functions to reach out to potential customers. The difference between the two lies in how they operate. Let’s simplify how both of them works.

Direct Selling

  • Personally reaching out to consumers – Direct sales is done by talking to people in real-time. This helps you better gauge what consumers really want and helps you adjust accordingly.
  • Fewer expenses mean greater potential profit – you don’t have to go through wholesalers, advertising, retailers and all the long processes. You can skip the middle man and his means less cost for your business. Having less cost means you have the flexibility to lower your product prices and be able to compete against known brands.
  • One dimensional – It only involves engaging sales talk with consumers. Which means it will be easy to manage. Analyzing sales data in this method is also easy.
  • Requires thick skin and excellent people skills – I believe that my direct selling experience has built up my confidence, public speaking skills, and critical thinking skills. Once you build up these mental and emotional muscles, you can utilize them in many areas of your life.

Direct Marketing

  • Use of advertising strategies on a tight budget – Direct marketing uses cost-efficient marketing strategies that help promote and showcase your products to consumers remotely.
  • Customer responses are measured – responses of customers can be counted and measured. This means that you can measure the effectiveness of the marketing campaigns you’ve implemented. You can set a sales goal for a marketing campaign to determine if it’s a success or not. You can then make decisions like discontinuing the campaign or prolonging it based on its’ performance.
  • Catered to a specific group of consumers – Direct marketing is designed to focus on a specific group of consumers – your target audience. Focusing on a specific group helps make your advertising more appealing by engaging consumers in a personal style of advertising.
  • Using data to adapt to consumers’ needs – Through customers responses, you can get an idea of what is the current trend among consumers. This will help you gain new customers and keep old customers. You can use loyalty rewards, discounts, coupons, limited-time offers, and package deals to keep customers always excited about your product.

Which is Better Between the 2?

Both work well, but it really depends on your business model and your return-on-investment (ROI). There are various factors for determining this. To better illustrate this, I’ll finish off with a couple of scenarios.

Scenario 1:

I have an herbal supplement business where I sell all-natural sleeping pills. There are a lot of competitors in the market, but I’m selling a premium product that requires a bit more information and selling since it has little known ingredients that help people get a good nights sleep and feel fully rested when they wake up in the morning.  All of that without feeling the grogginess of traditional sleeping pills. Each bottle sells for $27 and provides a $15 commission.

Scenario 2:

I’m selling financial services. This includes life insurance, health, and retirement products. Each of these products requires a deep conversation to understand the prospects’ needs. The average commission is $500.

High-Level Plan for Both Scenarios:

  • Contact at least 100 people a day using any offline or online strategy (cold calling, online/offline ads, etc).
  • The target audience consists of married homeowners with an age range between 30-45 years old.

Going back to the question, should I use direct selling or direct marketing? What strategy is worth my time, energy, and money?

Scenario 1 Direct Marketing Plan

While herbal supplements can offer great profits through high margins, you have to ask yourself if it’s worth your time to sell these directly. Let’s say that you spend a half-hour of your time using direct selling. Out of 7 sales presentations, you make 1 sale. In 1 day, you make around 2 sales which are equivalent to $15-30 in commissions.

If you’re looking to create a highly profitable business, direct selling wouldn’t be the proper solution for this business model. Instead, you could use online advertising or promote the supplement through low-cost media. Think about how Facebook, Instagram, or Youtube influencers build up a huge following and then pitch them through social media posts.

Without the influencer status, you can also pay for ads on these platforms. This is how you would use direct response marketing on social media. From there, you would have to determine if it’s worth paying for specific ads to keep your business profitable. For me, I would prefer to use email marketing instead of sending visitors straight to a product pitch. In that way, I could use email marketing to promote products to my audience over a longer period of time. Here’s a free e-course on this if you’d like to learn more.

Scenario 2 Hybrid Plan:

I know that if I use direct selling, I could build a personal connection and increase my conversion rate. Based on past performance, direct sales for scenario 2 is 1 out of 10. So out of 100 people, I can close 10 people on average and that means I can possibly make $5000.

So what are my options? I can cold call 100 people. However, it’s going to be tough to directly sell to 100 people if I want to close 10 people.  If I have a budget, I could use direct marketing using online ads or direct mail to get lukewarm prospects that might convert easier.

For direct response, the typical response rate is 1-2%. With direct mail or paid ads, there’s a cost associated to them and you would subtract that from the $5000 in commission. So let’s say that it cost $50 a lead. With ten leads, it would cost $500. If you wanted to get 100 leads, that would cost $5000 and would break even. These are all examples and the cost depends on the advertising platform.

Another alternative is using low-cost or free forms of advertising such as Facebook Events, Craigslist, local library or community center ads, or business cards.

From there, I would use the ads to have prospects sign up for a free newsletter so that I could build my own database. This will allow me to promote upcoming free financial workshops, provide awesome information, and do light direct selling along the way. It’s easier to do this using email marketing vs using direct mail for follow-ups.

I hope that you’ve found this article beneficial! If you have more questions about direct selling and marketing, feel free to let us know!